Home » Substitutes » Top Substitute for Nutritional yeast

Top Substitute for Nutritional yeast


If you’ve ever created a vegan “cheesy” dish, you have likely consumed nutritional yeast. For those looking to avoid dairy due to intolerances, this product has been a lifesaver. Below is a substitute for nutritional yeast list for these times when you need a replacement.

What is nutritional yeast?

Nutritional yeast is commonly used in vegan dishes as a substitute for cheese. It adds flavor and a small amount of color to recipes as it has a yellow tinge to it. Yeast has a long history of use, starting from Egyptian times, as evidenced by ruins. About 150 years ago, scientists began looking into the benefits of yeast further, and this investigation planted the seed for the production of nutritional yeast. In the 1970s, this product became widely popular for its state health benefits.

Nutritional yeast is different from standard yeast in that it is inactive, so it cannot be used for baking. This fungus is derived from various sources, such as molasses, though it does not have a sweet taste. Most often, you’ll find this form of yeast in savory dishes. However, on occasion, recipes call for nutritional yeast in sweet-tasting meals like smoothies.

Top Nutritional Yeast Substitutes

1.Soy Sauce

Soy sauce works as a nutritional yeast substitute due to its umami taste, similar to nutritional yeast. If you’re seeking an alternative that will aid in providing flavor to a dish, soy sauce works well. Use soy sauce in sauces, soups, and other dishes that have a liquid element.

Most people already have a bottle of this condiment in their fridge or cupboard, making it an accessible item to grab in the absence of nutritional yeast. This sauce does not work well for all recipes – especially those that use a large amount of yeast. As you would probably guess, you will not want to use soy sauce in any sweet recipes like smoothies.

Pros
Soy sauce is a tasty ingredient that can be used in many savory recipes instead of nutritional yeast. It’s easy to find in stores, though you probably already have a bottle of it in your house.

Cons
You’ll notice that soy sauce has a bolder flavor than nutritional yeast. Because of this, it is easy to use too much while cooking. Not only will this potentially overpower other ingredients, but it can also make the recipe too salty to consume.

Cooking Tip:
Use ½ tablespoon of soy sauce for every tablespoon of nutritional yeast.

2. White Miso Paste

While white miso paste might seem like an odd alternative, it works as one of the better substitutes for nutritional yeast. White miso also provides a “meaty”/umami taste when used in dishes. This paste also provides a similar nutty flavor.

If you’ve never heard of white miso paste before, it is created from fermented soybeans. Depending on the manufacturer, some brands may include additional ingredients like rice and millet. When using this paste in hot dishes, add it in last for the best flavor.

Pros
This alternative provides a similar flavor to nutritional yeast. Use miso paste in dishes that have a liquid base like soups. This ingredient must be dissolved into a recipe.

Cons
Miso paste is also quite salty, like soy sauce. Again, it can be overwhelming when used in recipes. This paste does not work in dishes where nutritional yeast is used as a garnish. It is not easy to find white miso at general grocery stores. Though if you have an Asian market nearby, you’ll likely find this swap there.

Cooking Tip:
Use 1/3 of the amount of white miso paste that the recipe calls for.

3. Cashews

Those familiar with vegan cooking will know that cashews are an excellent nutritional yeast alternative. Cashews are another staple in vegan recipes that can be used to create cheesy sauces and creamy soups. Not only do they work well in sauces, but they also can be pulverized and used as a topping or garnish like nutritional yeast.

Cashews provide a nutty flavor and a much different texture, even when in ground form. No umami flavor is present, so there will be a flavor difference when using cashews instead of yeast. When using cashews in a sauce, ensure they have soaked ahead of time; otherwise, the consistency will be chunky instead of smooth.

Pros
This replacement works well for those who are only seeking a cheesy and nutty flavor in a recipe. Cashews are versatile as they can be used dry as a topping or soaked in dips and even smoothies. If you don’t have cashews in your kitchen, you can find a bag at the closest store.

Cons
The umami flavor is missing from this alternative, causing the final dish to taste different. While cashews are easy to find, they are pretty pricey and may be out of budget for some.

Cooking Tip:
Cashews can be used in a 1:1 ratio instead of nutritional yeast.

4. Brewer’s Yeast

Brewer’s yeast is created using the same fungus strain that nutritional yeast uses. However, it is formulated using beer most often, which adds a bitter flavor. It also is sold in a flake form and is seen in the store as an inactive yeast.

While the flavor is not the same, it is an excellent nutritional yeast replacement. It aids in thickening soups and dips as well. You’ll still find this alternative provides a cheesy flavor though it lacks a nuttiness and meaty taste. It is bolder, so you’ll want to use less in your recipes.

Pros
This yeast works well to provide both a thick consistency to dishes as well as a cheese flavor. Use it in cheesy sauces and dips as a substitution for nutritional yeast.

Cons
Regarding flavor, you’ll find that brewer’s yeast is quite different. When cooking with this replacement, the taste will be noticeable. If too much is used, it can cause the dish to become bitter or overpowered. Brewer’s yeast is not easy to find at local grocery stores. It may need to be ordered online.

Cooking Tip:
Use ½ the amount of brewer’s yeast that the recipe calls for.

5. Parmesan Cheese

Parmesan cheese works well as a substitution as it provides a similar nutty flavor to dishes. Nutritional yeast is typically a replacement for parmesan cheese in recipes for those who have reactions to dairy or are vegan. If you have no issues consuming dairy, you can make the reverse swap by using parmesan instead.

When using parmesan, alter the amount of salt that is in the dish. Parmesan contains a higher sodium level than nutritional yeast, which will make the recipe overly salty if not modified.

This cheese is most often used in Italian cuisine. However, you can also use it as a replacement for any dish that calls for nutritional yeast. Try parmesan on pasta dishes, pizza, vegetables, and salads.

Pros
Parmesan works well in any dish that requires nutritional yeast. The flavor profile is very similar, yet parmesan cheese provides gooeyness to recipes. You can find parmesan in any grocery store if you don’t have some in your fridge already.

Cons
As noted, this swap does include dairy. It is not a good substitution for those who can’t or don’t eat dairy.

Cooking Tip:
Use as a swap in a 1:1 ratio.

6. Coconut Aminos

Coconut aminos are commonly used in vegan recipes as a seasoning alternative. You will notice there is a difference in consistency as aminos are sold in liquid form, whereas nutritional yeast is offered in a flake form. However, there is a similar taste that makes coconut aminos work well as a replacement.

These aminos are often compared to soy sauce both for color, consistency, and also taste. When using coconut aminos, you’ll note a nutty, sweet, salty, slightly fruity taste. Choose this liquid replacement when making dishes that are saucy or soupy. You will want to avoid using this swap to top salads or other dishes without a liquid component.

As the popularity of coconut aminos grows, it is more easily found in grocery stores. However, you may still have some trouble finding it at your local store if there is not a demand for it. Beyond that, the sweetness and slightly fruity taste will alter the flavor of your dishes.

Pros
Coconut aminos provide a taste that is similar to nutritional yeast in dishes. It works well in liquid-based recipes as a replacement.

Cons
You cannot use coconut aminos in recipes that do not have sauces. This swap may also not be at all grocery stores. The flavor does vary, which will change the taste of the dish.

Cooking Tip:
Use ½ the amount required by the recipe and add more if needed.

7. Chickpea Flour

Chickpea flour, also known as garbanzo bean flour, is made by pulverizing dried chickpeas until they become a fine powder. This flour also provides a nutty taste. However, it has a prominent bean flavor and can be drier tasting than nutritional yeast. You’ll also find chickpea flour lacks a cheesy taste.

This flour is most commonly used in Indian and Middle Eastern dishes like falafel. If you live near a store with a sizeable ethnic section or an Indian grocery store, you’ll easily find this ingredient. If not, you will need to order it online as your local store likely does not have it.

While people usually opt for nutritional yeast for flavor, it also aids in thickening dishes. Chickpea flour works excellently in this regard. As it’s a dry powder, it can also be used topping for snacks like popcorn.

Pros
Chickpea flour is excellent as a thickener and adds a nutty flavor to dishes. Use it in both sauces and as a topping for foods.

Cons
The flavor profile lacks a cheesy taste, so you’ll need to add additional seasoning to mimic the flavor more closely. It may not be easy to find this replacement in stores. You can make your own at home. However, it can be time-consuming.

Cooking Tip:
Use ½ of the amount listed in the recipe.

8. Dried Mushroom

When you’re creating dishes that require a “meaty” taste, dried mushrooms work well. You will find they lack a cheesy flavor and salty taste that is provided by nutritional yeast. However, you can easily remedy the saltiness by adding a small amount of salt into the recipe.

There are multiple ways you can use dried mushrooms, including finely ground, pulverized into a powder, and even rehydrated. This allows for more cooking possibilities.

The variety of dried mushrooms chosen will also affect the flavor as some mushrooms (like porcini mushrooms) will also provide a nutty taste. Use dried mushrooms in soups and cooked vegetable-based dishes.

Pros
This swap adds an umami flavor to dishes and can be used in multiple ways.

Cons
Not all flavor notes are present in dried mushrooms. You will not be able to replicate a cheesy flavor with this substitute.

Cooking Tip:
Use in a 1:1 ratio when using mushroom powder.

FAQs

What does nutritional yeast do in a recipe?

Nutritional yeast is used for adding flavor to vegan recipes. It provides a nutty, umami, or cheesy taste that many uses instead of cheese. Nutritional yeast is excellent as in vegan cheese recipes like vegan cheese sauce.

Can you skip nutritional yeast in a recipe?

Technically, yes, you can skip nutritional yeast in a recipe. This is true only for recipes that require small amounts of nutritional yeast. You will notice less flavor than usual and may need to add other seasonings to account for the taste. This is not a good solution for vegan mac and cheese recipes, where the dish relies on a cheesy flavor.

Is nutritional yeast a good cheese substitute?

Yes, if you have a dairy intolerance or dietary restrictions, you can substitute nutritional yeast as a good alternative. It does not provide an exact flavor match. However, it adds a cheesy taste and can help satisfy cheese cravings.

Can you substitute parmesan cheese for nutritional yeast?

If you find a recipe that usually requires nutritional yeast, you can use parmesan instead. This is ideal for those who are not vegan and who don’t have dietary restrictions in place. It will provide a cheesy taste in your recipes and is best used in savory menu items.

Summary

Next time you consider how to replace nutritional yeast, consider the above choices first. You’ll be surprised at how tasty each one is. Soy sauce and white miso paste are your best bets for adding an umami flavor to your favorite dishes. Chickpea flour and yeast extract (like marmite) are additional items that make replacing nutritional yeast easy.

Try each of the listed choices to see what works best with your tastebuds. Keep an open mind, and you’ll be surprised at how well the flavors mimic nutritional yeast.

Related Articles

Natalia | Flavorful home
Natalia is a recipe developer, food photographer, and home cook. She started Flavorful Home to document her recipes and share home cooking tips. She loves creating flavorful and nutritious meals while keeping the cooking process simple and joyful!

Get new recipes and tips via email
when you subscribe!

Leave a Reply

Quick Search