Home » Uncategorized » How to reheat stuffed peppers (4 Easy Methods)

How to reheat stuffed peppers (4 Easy Methods)


This article will teach you how to reheat stuffed peppers in four effortless ways! Stuffed peppers are delicious, not that hard to make, and perfect as leftovers! Some might even agree that leftovers warmed up the next day taste even better.

Making this dish is not really that complicated, but it may involve quite a bit of preparation. This is probably why many home cooks make them in big batches.

It is essential to know how to reheat stuffed peppers and enjoy them later. Below are the methods you can try for reheating your leftover stuffed peppers, so they taste just about as good as day one.

cast iron skillet filled with stuffed peppers topped with cheese

Methods for Reheating Stuffed Peppers:

There are four ways to reheat stuffed peppers: in the oven, in the microwave, in the air fryer, or in the skillet. Keep reading to find the best tips and how to do it!

Oven Method Tips

Reheating stuffed bell peppers in the oven is the best method since it reheats them perfectly without getting soggy, which helps in retaining the taste and texture. Although it might take a little longer than the other methods, the delicious stuffed peppers you get in the end are worth the effort and waiting time.

You can use this method for reheating stuffed bell peppers from frozen or fresh peppers.

Ensure that the stuffed peppers are piping hot when serving to enjoy them fully.

Pros:

An advantage of reheating stuffed peppers in the oven is that you can do it without defrosting them first. The filling will be moist and you won’t be able to tell if the stuffed peppers were previously frozen.

Cons:

Reheating the frozen ones directly may take a few extra minutes to heat up properly. So, if you’re in a rush, you may want to choose another method below.

white baking dish with stuffed peppers

reheating stuffed peppers in the oven Steps

Step 1. Preheat the oven to 350°F (180°C).

Preheating the oven to 350 degrees is the ideal oven temperature for peppers. This ensures that the food is heated through to the middle and evenly heated without burning the outside. If you are in a hurry, use the microwave, place stuffed peppers in for a 20-to 30-second blast.

Step 2. Place the stuffed peppers in an oven-proof casserole and cover.

Line up the stuffed peppers in the oven-proof dish with the stuffing facing upwards. This will ensure that the filling does not leak out as the peppers reheat. 

Avoid stacking the peppers on top of each other, as this may cause the bottom layer to collapse.

Do not also forget to cover the casserole with aluminum foil or with the lid it comes with if available. This will make sure that the peppers don’t get too hot and dry out.

Step 3. Bake for 15 to 45 minutes.

Bake for 15 minutes if fresh or defrosted, and 45 minutes if frozen. Remove the glass lid and bake for 5 more minutes to create those cheesy, golden, crispy edges.

Step 4. Serve!

Take the casserole out of the oven and serve. 

Notes:

  • Since we want our reheated stuffed peppers to be piping hot throughout, it is best to check their temperature using a food thermometer. This step is essential if you are reheating frozen stuffed peppers with meat.
  • You want the internal temperature to reach 165°F (74°C).

Microwave Method Tips

Using a microwave is the fastest and most convenient method of reheating stuffed peppers. This is perfect for individuals who are in a hurry. The bell peppers would taste great and be ready in just a couple of minutes.

For best results use the microwave method on defrosted stuffed peppers. If you are in a hurry and need to reheat frozen peppers, opt to use the defrost function of your microwave to speed things up.

Pros:

Also, it is a more cost-effective method compared to the oven, since you can economically heat only a portion or two, which is not worth heating in the oven. 

Cons:

However, a downside to this method is that the stuffed peppers may lose their texture, causing them to become soggy and watery.

reheating stuffed peppers in the microwave Steps

Step 1. Place the stuffed peppers on a microwave-safe dish.

Place your stuffed peppers on a microwave-safe dish that can safely go into the microwave. Ensure that the peppers are facing upwards to prevent the filling from leaking out. Also, do not put the stuffed peppers on top of each other. As much as possible, reheat one to two portions at a time to get the best results.

Cutting the peppers in half before placing them in the microwave might be helpful, but it is not essential. Some people say that doing this is the best way to reheat stuffed peppers.

Step 2. Cover the peppers.

Cover the microwave dish with a wet paper towel. This will help your food cook evenly and keep it moist.

Step 3. Microwave it for two minutes.

Place the plate in the microwave and turn it on for 2 minutes on high. Before taking them out, check the peppers to see if they are already heated enough. If not, heat the peppers again at intervals of 10 to 15 seconds to avoid overcooking, which may result in mushy and wet peppers. Repeat this process until they are satisfactorily heated through.

Step 4. Serve!

Take out the microwave-safe plate and allow the peppers to sit for 60 seconds before serving. Since the peppers are very hot, transferring them to another plate immediately may cause them to fall apart. 

You may also want to cut them in half to see if they are cooked evenly or heated all the way through. Enjoy!

Air Fryer Method Tips

Reheating stuffed peppers in an air fryer is an excellent option as it is faster than using an oven but still more flavorsome than the microwave. Also, it does not lose its texture, which occurs when reheated in the microwave. Similar to using an oven, both refrigerated and frozen peppers may be reheated in the air fryer. 

Pros:

A good compromise between an oven and a microwave. It is quicker than using the oven and more flavorful than using the microwave.

Cons:

You can only reheat in small batches compared to using an oven.

Reheating stuffed peppers using an air fryer steps

Step 1. Preheat the air fryer to 350F degrees.

Step 2. Arrange the stuffed peppers on the air fryer tray or basket.

Make sure to spray your tray with non-stick cooking spray or use a paper liner before putting the peppers on it. Then, place the stuffed peppers into the air fryer basket while making sure that they are upright and not touching each other. If you want to let air flow around the stuffed peppers, make sure they are not leaning against each other.

Step 3. Heat it for around 10 minutes. 

Reheat the stuffed peppers in the air fryer. It may take about 5 minutes to reheat in the air fryer for chilled peppers. For frozen ones, it may take about 15 minutes. You would want to check it after the specified minutes to see if it is adequately heated through. Extend the heating time if necessary.

If you heat the peppers in the microwave first, it will only take 8 to 15 minutes. If not, it will likely take 15 to 20 minutes. 

Step 4. Serve!

Take the air fryer tray or basket out and serve. 

Notes:

Like when using an oven, it is best to check their temperature using a food thermometer since we want our reheated stuffed peppers piping hot throughout. You want the internal temperature to reach 165F degrees.

If the filling is denser, it may take longer to warm through. That’s why it’s a good idea to do the initial blasting in the microwave, particularly if your peppers are stuffed with meat and rice.

Skillet Method Tips

Using a skillet to reheat stuffed peppers might differ from the other options listed here. It is not your traditional way of heating this dish. Skillet stuffed peppers are usually a one-pan recipe. It is equally as flavorful and tasty as the traditional stuffed peppers but easier to prepare since everything cooks in the same pan or skillet. If you love stuffed peppers, then you’ll definitely love these too.

Leftovers can be refrigerated in an airtight container and consumed within 3 to 4 days to get the best quality. If you want to store it longer, you may store it in a freezer-safe container and freeze it for up to 3 months. 

Pros:

Preparation and clean-up are easy because you will only use one skillet pan.

Cons:

It is quite different from traditional stuffed peppers.

Reheating stuffed peppers on the stove steps

Step 1. Thaw overnight in the fridge.

The night before reheating, make sure to thaw your frozen peppers safely overnight in the refrigerator. 

Step 2. Reheat on the stovetop.

Heat your peppers in a skillet over low to medium heat. Make sure not to put it on high heat to avoid burning.

Step 3. Serve!

Garnish heated peppers with parsley or green onions, depending on your liking. Enjoy!

white plate with stuffed peppers topped with melted cheese

Tips to keep stuffed peppers from Getting soggy

Here are some tips to prevent stuffed peppers from getting soggy: 

  • Choose to reheat using an oven or air fryer – This is one of the simplest ways to prevent your stuffed peppers from becoming soggy after heating. Your peppers may not have the same texture as when they were freshly cooked, but you get a better texture than the other reheating methods. This is way better than putting them in a microwave, where they nearly always get soggy.
  • Let the stuffed pepper cool. Before freezing, make sure that you let your stuffed peppers cool completely so they don’t become soggy. Freezing them while warm is a big no-no, as this will also lead to excess moisture when defrosted later—placing them in the refrigerator to chill for 3 to 4 hours before freezing is also a good idea. 
  • Use quinoa and add oats. Substituting rice with quinoa and adding a tablespoon of quick-cooking oats should keep your stuffed peppers from soggy after cooking and reheating. The filling will soak up all the excess juice in the filling. 
  • Keep the pepper-side up. Arrange them in the baking dish with the pepper side up to hold the shape and look presentable later.

Extra Tips for reheating stuffed peppers

  • Do not reheat leftover stuffed peppers more than once. 
  • If you prefer to add cheese toppings when making stuffed peppers, it’s best to add them when reheating rather than before freezing them.
  • If your stuffed peppers contain rice, do not leave them at room temperature for a long period of time after cooking.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you freeze stuffed peppers?

Yes. Since most people prepare this dish in large quantities in advance, freezing stuffed peppers and then reheating them in the coming days is common practice. The taste of frozen cooked stuffed peppers will still be the same as freshly prepared stuffed peppers.

How to freeze stuffed peppers?

Before anything else, let the stuffed peppers cool completely to room temperature after cooking. Once cooled, place them in the refrigerator for around 3 to 4 hours or overnight as a pre-chill process. Then pack them into portion-sized airtight containers.

Leftover stuffed peppers will last for up to 3 to 6 months in the freezer.

How long can you keep cooked stuffed peppers in the refrigerator?

Stuffed peppers are best stored for 3 to 4 days if chilled and 3 to 6 months if frozen. It is better to reheat only as many stuffed peppers as needed for a meal because reheating them more than once might affect the taste and consistency.

However, if your leftover stuffed peppers have rice in them, you should eat them within 24 hours.

How to defrost frozen stuffed peppers?

Refrigeration is the safest technique to thaw frozen stuffed peppers. Leaving them out in the open to defrost will create a bacteria buildup and cause spoilage.

But did you know that you do not necessarily have to defrost frozen stuffed peppers? If you are reheating them in an oven or air fryer, you can simply pop them straight from the freezer.

How to reheat frozen stuffed peppers?

As discussed above, there are four ways to reheat frozen stuffed peppers: the oven, microwave, air fryer, and skillet. But the best way to reheat frozen stuffed peppers is in the oven or air fryer because, in these methods, you do not need to defrost or thaw.

How to store stuffed peppers?

Let the stuffed peppers cool before storing them in an airtight container. Remember to cover it with the lid or aluminum foil. Keep in mind that leftover stuffed peppers only last 4 days in the fridge.

What are the signs that cooked peppers have gone off?

If your leftover stuffed pepper is starting to change color, it’s time to toss them for sure. And even if you have some doubts, simply sniff it. If the smell is not fresh, it’s better to toss it.

Should you freeze cooked or raw stuffed peppers?

Cooked stuffed peppers are safer to freeze than raw ones. Cook stuffed peppers completely and to avoid mushy stuffed peppers later, let them cool completely before freezing.

Related Articles

Natalia | Flavorful home
Natalia is a recipe developer, food photographer, and home cook. She started Flavorful Home to document her recipes and share home cooking tips. She loves creating flavorful and nutritious meals while keeping the cooking process simple and joyful!

Get new recipes and tips via email
when you subscribe!

Leave a Reply

Quick Search