You’ve most likely consumed sour cream in one form or another over the years. You never truly realize how many recipes use sour cream until you forget to buy sour cream at the store. Below you’ll find a substitute for sour cream for any occasion or recipe.
Surprisingly, sour cream is a newer ingredient that only started being used in Western countries in the 1900s. It originated in Eastern Europe (specifically Russia) and was initially created by leaving the cream out until it soured. This is where the name sour cream originates.
Sour cream is an updated version of a sour alcoholic milk drink (Kumis) The Mongols consumed. As they traveled across Europe, more people were exposed to the drink and started getting creative over the years with the ways they created it, thus producing sour cream in the early 20th century.
Now, it is created by taking cream and adding lactic acid bacteria to it, creating a sour taste. It’s very similar to the process of making yogurt. It contains vitamins like A, B2, B12, as well as minerals and calcium.
Below you’ll find a list of alternatives for those who have run out of sour cream or need a dairy-free substitute. Cooking tips are also listed for each option.
Greek yogurt is the next best sour cream substitute. It provides both the sour flavor and a similar consistency as sour cream does. It’s also relatively easy to bake with and adds moisture to any sweet loaves you make (like banana bread). Greek yogurt also works well with savory dishes – like a topping for chili, soup, or even tacos.
Greek yogurt is preferable over standard yogurt as it provides a thickness that mimics sour cream better. It’s also easy to swap out full-fat Greek yogurt for low-fat Greek yogurt in recipes without sacrificing flavor, moisture, or taste. Greek yogurt is an excellent source of protein and provides a lower fat content and number of calories than full-fat sour cream.
Cottage cheese is another excellent sour cream replacement. While it may lack the tangy taste associated with sour cream, it provides a creaminess and dairy taste to dishes in which you use it. Many people use cottage cheese as a healthy alternative in their dishes due to the amount of protein, essential nutrients, and low calories it contains. It has a subtle flavor, so you can add it to most dishes without overwhelming the other ingredients or seasonings.
Cottage cheese works best to replace cooked recipes like soups, sauces, or even baked goods. Keep in mind; cottage cheese does have added salt in it, so you may want to use less additional salt in your dishes when using this swap.
Crème Fraiche is another sour cream replacement that can be easily used in many recipes. It’s richer and heavier than sour cream, so you’ll want to use this for more decadent dishes. Consuming this ingredient in moderation is key.
Crème Fraiche is typically available in most grocery stores and can be found in the same section that sour cream is generally in. If your local store is out of sour cream – you can grab a container of this instead. The process of creating crème Fraiche is nearly identical to sour cream as it requires the use of heavy cream and a bacterial culture. It does have a thicker consistency and lacks the tangy taste sour cream provides. Crème Fraiche works well in sauces and soups to create thick and decadent final products.
Buttermilk is a great sour cream baking substitute. It provides a similar sour taste to any desserts it’s added to. Due to its thinner consistency, it’s ideal for use in baked goods, dips, or salad dressings. It is not recommended to use buttermilk as a topping as it will be too runny and will make the food soggy. Initially, buttermilk was created by letting milk stay out at room temperature until the cream separated. This process allowed the leftover liquid to ferment. Now, it is created by heating milk and adding bacteria in after the heating process.
If you’re swapping sour cream out for a dairy allergy or dietary restrictions, coconut milk is a fantastic sour cream alternative. You’ll find coconut cream to have a slightly sweet and coconutty flavor, though this does not mean it can’t be used for savory dishes. Coconut milk provides a thick consistency and decadence to any meal it’s included in. It comes specifically from mature coconuts with a brown exterior.
If you’re seeking a replacement for sour cream in baked goods, you can use the coconut as-is or add one tablespoon of lemon juice for that same tanginess. For savory dishes, use the same lemon juice (or vinegar) plus a sprinkle of salt. Use a 1:1 ratio for coconut milk.
Vegan sour cream is another substitution for sour cream that is great for those avoiding dairy. With veganism becoming more apparent in recent years, it’s now easier than ever to find alternatives like this at your local grocery store.
The benefit of using vegan sour cream is that it mimics standard sour cream quite well in flavor and consistency. You may notice a slightly different taste, as most are made from coconut cream, almond milk, or tofu though it’s still a great replacement. It’s also a great alternative as it has no restrictions on what can be done with it. This is one of the most versatile options for a sour cream substitution.
Cashews are commonly used in vegan cooking as a thickening agent or a base for soups, sauces, and even a topping. They can also create rich, thick dips in a pinch and don’t require much preparation. In other words, they are a great sour cream substitute. They’re excellent for creating creaminess in dishes due to their high-fat content.
In order to use cashews as a replacement, you’ll need to make homemade cashew sour cream. Add cashews, lime juice (or apple cider vinegar), and salt to a blender until a creamy consistency and minimal lumps are achieved. You can add more lime juice during this process if you’re seeking a thinner cashew sour cream. The final product is a tangy and rich version of a dairy-free sour cream. Cashew sour cream is not ideal for baked goods, though it can be used for most other recipes.
Yes, you can substitute milk for sour cream in recipes like sauces or soups. Again, you’ll want to add two tablespoons of lemon juice to provide the tangy taste sour cream offers. You can use this alternative for both savory and sweet desserts, though you may find sweet desserts less moist with this method, particularly sweet loaves.
While it depends on the recipe you’re using; a few good substitutes are Greek yogurt or vegan sour cream. Both work well to provide a tangy taste and similar consistency.
You can use buttermilk to replace sour cream in banana bread. It provides a similar flavor and adds richness to the banana bread. Another great option is cream cheese – it can be mixed directly into the batter for a decadent loaf.
From a calorie perspective, sour cream is healthier. Two tablespoons of sour cream contain 52 calories, while one tablespoon of mayo has approximately double the amount.
Homemade sour cream and vegan sour cream offer the best switches for your culinary needs. Both are versatile, provide the same taste and sourness, and match the consistency. In a pinch, you can use Greek yogurt as a backup option if you don’t have time to create sour cream or can’t find vegan sour cream at your nearest store – even as a topping for baked potatoes.
The above list will help you cook with confidence even when you notice you are out of sour cream, are seeking a healthier alternative, or looking for a dairy-free option.